Soft vs. Hard Dog Treats: Which Chews Are Best for Your Dog?

Adult dog sitting beside soft and hard dog treats,  dog chews in different textures.

Dogs have their own chewing quirks. Some are happiest gnawing away at something firm, chomping down on anything tough enough for a challenge. Others, though, would rather have something softer to chew on than a treat that puts their jaws to work. 

The better pick will always depend on their age, size, dental condition, and chewing style. Some dogs simply do better with a softer bite, a gentler option for dogs who struggle with harder, crunchier bites. While appropriately selected firm chews gives your dog some added benefits other than sparing your furniture from being  gnawed on or getting that  extra time for yourself by keeping their boredom at bay… for longer.

A little know-how on which one to choose goes a long way toward keeping your furry buddy in tip top shape. 

Let's get into the nitty-gritty of what sets each treat apart.... and how to pick one that won't leave your four-legged food critic turning up his nose.

Soft Dog Treats: A Softer Bite for Dogs Who Like It Easy 

Unlike hard, crunchy treats, these are softer, easier to bite into, and a little more forgiving on the teeth. They break apart more easily with each bite. A good choice for dogs who prefer their treats on the softer side.

This can also be especially helpful for certain groups of dogs, such as senior dogs, young pups with developing teeth, picky eaters, or those dogs born with exceptionally weak jaws.

Why Senior Dogs May Benefit from Soft Treats

A dog's teeth don't stay in perfect shape forever. With age, they can become worn, loose, or fall out altogether. Add sore gums to the mix, and even chewing their favorite food can become a bit of a struggle. That said, older dogs with dental problems are better off with softer treats. Their teeth have done enough work over the years; no need to make them struggle with rock-hard snacks.

However, according to the American Animal Hospital Association (AAHA), while it’s true that senior pets are more prone to oral health problems, we can’t  hastily chalk their dental issues up to the years. Have a vet take a look, as there could be an underlying issue worth looking into.

It's also worth considering that if your dog's teeth are still in good shape and he has no trouble chewing, there's no need to take the crunch out of snack time just because he's getting older. Let's not be too quick to rule out crunchy treats because they can still do an older dog some good. 

Dogs with Dental Limitations

As for dogs fresh out of a dental procedure, soft dog treats may be just what their sore mouths need, although their veterinarian must call the shots on when hard treats can make a comeback, including advice on which textures won't cause trouble. 

Keep in mind that soft treats are nice to have, but they won't clear up periodontal disease or take away dental pain. If your dog suddenly turns up his nose at hard food, starts dropping treats, or chews on just one side of his mouth, it’s worth booking a dental check. 

Handy for Training and Treat Time

There's no reason to reward one successful command with an entire snack. Soft treats can be broken into smaller pieces, allowing you to stretch your supply through a training session. Your dog gets his little victories. You get to keep the treat budget under control.

If you’re looking for a soft dog chew, here are a couple of our bestsellers 

Lovin' Tenders Chicken Breast Fillets Recipe
Butcher Shop Chicken Fillets Recipe

2. Hard Dog Chews

The right hard chew can be good for our furry companions; it can help support dental health, satisfy their natural chewing instincts, and give their minds a much needed workout.

Chewing Stimulate Your Furry Pal’s Brain

Dogs need to stretch their brains, too. A good walk is great, but a little mental stimulation goes a long way in keeping them happy and engaged. The simple, repetitive act of chewing not only  keeps a dog happily occupied, it also engages their senses, gives their mind a little workout, and lets them indulge in an instinct that comes naturally to them.

Chewing is practically a dog's way of getting to know the world. If it has an interesting texture, chances are, it'll end up between those teeth. We can toss some treats at them with different textures, shapes, and resistance to play with— our way of giving their jaws something to work on and their minds something to dig into.

Hard Chews for Dogs Help Reduce Plaque and Tartar

The friction can help scrub off some plaque and slow down tartar buildup. The back-and-forth chewing creates friction against the teeth, helping knock loose food bits and scrape away some of the plaque that builds up during the day. 

You could say firm chews are the long-playing version of dog treats. Instead of gobbling them up in seconds, dogs get to take their time, chewing and gnawing away at something made for just that.

Hard Dog Treats May Help Relieve Stress

For some dogs, chewing is a little like winding down after a long day. The steady, rhythmic movement of the jaws gives them something to focus on, provides sensory stimulation, and can help take the edge off when they're agitated or overly stimulated.

Every dog has a chewing habit we can’t overlook when choosing dog treats. 

Some dogs chew now and then; others seem to have an endless need to gnaw. Either way, knowing your dog's chewing habits helps you find a treat that suits them.. The right texture can turn an ordinary treat into the highlight of their day. 

Got a dog who tears through regular treats in minutes? A harder chew might be a better choice. The following hard dog treats or chews  are worth considering: 

Butcher Shop Collagen Dog Chews 5" Deluxe Chicken Twists Recipe 

Lovin' Tenders 8" Chicken & Rawhide Rolls Recipe 

Lovin' Tenders Chicken & Duck Tenders Recipe

Butcher Shop 8" Chicken & Rawhide Rolls Recipe 

Hard chews can be thoroughly entertaining for dogs, but there's a limit to what their teeth can take. So look for chews that offer a bit of resistance without being too tough for them to bite down on.